Ableton 10 vs logic pro x reddit free
Looking for:
Logic Pro vs Ableton: Which is The Better DAW? - Guitar Space |
Ableton 10 vs logic pro x reddit free.Ableton vs Logic Pro | Which is right for YOU? (2022 Comparison)
Ableton 10 vs logic pro x reddit free. Logic Pro vs Ableton: Which is The Better DAW?
Always wanting to expand my horizons, I set out on a mission to produce a song in both Logic Pro X and Ableton Live Suite 10 to find out how they both stacked up against each other. I usually use Pro Tools , so this was a new experience for me as well, learning how to machete my way through each interface, figuring things out as I went.
I judged the DAWs on their ease of use, creativity, interface and price. This Mac-only system is easy to use and downloadable on every compatible Apple device you own.
Ableton Live Suite 10 is a favorite of musicians who perform live on stage. The interface is simple and easy to use and, along with a controller like the Ableton Push 2, can be a powerful tool for writing and performing music. Being two music-production powerhouses, the debate for which DAW is better between Ableton Live and Logic Pro X is an endless whirlwind of positive comparisons, with seldom a downside between them.
Ableton Live cornered its namesake in the live performance realm, garnering people producing and performing all types of electronic music.
Logic Pro was always considered the bedroom musician, Pro Tools. Cheaper but fully functional, pro studio quality, and feature-rich DAW. Used more in conjunction with producing full tracks to later be played live with CDJ's or the like. Fast-forward down the line for both of them, and the features of each started to become closely related Both of them serve as unique tools in the audio manipulation and MIDI programming paradigm.
Basically, anything a user needs to know about creating one's music as effectively as possible in each of the DAWs. Both music production powerhouses qualify as viable tools. Although Live can be used on Windows, for this article we will focus on both mac versions.
The linear workflow of a DAW is spent in the arrangement view. While every function has its window or sub-menu, this is your global view of your entire composition. Apple's Logic Pro has a more traditional linear view, and one in which you have full access to a single selected channel strip on the left side of the screen. This is nice for organization and making quick changes to your mix while arranging your clips, audio tracks, and MIDI tracks on the timeline.
You also have access to inserts, instruments, audio units midi fx, dynamics, and time-based effects, and sends to effects on auxiliary buses. If you wanted to, you could do an entire mix from the arrangement view.
Mouse pointer editing tools are also contained in the session view another name for arrangement view. Logic has a wealth of tools for selecting, slicing, fading, erasing, gluing, zooming, automating, and warping. Each of them can also be assigned to a single key command, so you can speed up workflows that you end up executing often. If you're a key command person, Logic is incredibly versatile. Double-clicking audio clips and MIDI clips from session view will subsequently bring up audio editor and piano roll editor windows respectively, letting you further oversee your entire composition from this multi-faceted space.
Ableton Live's session view is very similar to Logic's, as are most arrange views in any digital audio workstation. The differences are subtle but do make enough of an impact on the workflows. The layout of Ableton's arrange window has the insert section in its area on the bottom of the screen.
It also doesn't utilize traditional vertical insert slots, but instead a horizontal space where you can drag and drop, plug-ins, instruments, and even just plain audio files. Audio dropped there will immediately get converted into a sampler instrument, making the sampling workflow extremely fast.
Ableton Live has a much more condensed set of mouse pointer editing tools than Logic Pro X. They are also not activated by key commands, and instead utilize different parts of the clip or timeline to change functionality. For instance, hovering the mouse in the time ruler will show a magnifying glass.
This is your zoom tool so you can zoom in and out and make edits accordingly to your clips. Hovering your mouse just under the time ruler will result in a speaker icon, allowing you to click and play from that point in time. Placing your mouse at the edge of a clip will activate trimming, clicking in the area above the waveform will bring up a hand and allow you to move clips around, and clicking in the waveform area itself will let you make selections to cut audio and move it around accordingly.
Fades show up when you reach a certain zoom level and have UI for curves and fade length. Create Fades on Clip Edges is a preference you can turn on and off in the preferences and comes in handy for saving time when editing audio. The key differences in the edit window of each DAW make for very different workflows.
Key command users would prefer Logic Pro X, and appreciators of the what-you-see-is-what-get variety, Ableton Live excels. Ableton has an immensely useful collection of MIDI instruments, such as the extremely versatile and user-friendly, Wavetable Synth.
With 2 oscillators, it's not overpowering, yet it has a wide variety of wavetables to choose from, the routing matrix is easy to get used to, and the tonality can closely resemble an analog synth. Live also has an equally as powerful midi environment. MIDI data can be entered using the qwerty keyboard by enabling the keyboard icon in the top right.
Just turn it on and your keyboard is not able to send MIDI signals. As with the changing mouse tool in the arrange view, most things in Live are right there in front of you and do not require key commands or sub-menus.
In practice, though, linear music arrangement in any DAW is a delight. The winner of the linear arrangement in Logic Pro. The groundbreaking non-linear Session View clip recording and launching interface from Ableton Live took a few years to alter the world of music technology. Still, it established the de facto standard for laptop DJing and dance music creation and placed the Berlin-based business on the map.
This apparently benign Clip View control panel allows producers and live performers to automate and randomize clip-launching within Scenes, something no other DAW can accomplish. The winner of the loop arrangement is Ableton. Alchemy is the most obviously powerful of the two, taking in additive, granular, and analog-style synthesis, with four simultaneous inputs, gobs of filters, and abundant effects.
It was formerly an expensive third-party instrument until Apple purchased its developer, Camel Audio. On the other hand, wavetable is a two-oscillator plus sub wavetable synth with over well-crafted wavetables onboard, two filters, extensive modulation possibilities, and an extremely user-friendly interface and workflow.
Those two elements are essential for us. These new additions have been included to an outstanding lineup of distortion, dynamics, equalization the integrated Channel EQ is particularly noticeable , reverb, delay, modulation, and other effect types, giving you everything you need to finish your mixing job. Live differs from Logic in that it gives equal weight to sound design and mixing processors.
Depending on your major plugin requirements, this round of our face-off might go either way: Live is best used for sound design, and Logic is best used for mixing. Effects category is a draw! However, there are significant variances…. On the other hand, Live is about as lean and mean as DAWs come, with its less stratified, comparably approachable interface and the speed with which a seasoned user can jet about its Session and Arrange Views, Sample Editor, and Piano Roll is a special part of the software.
Back over the pond, Logic is known for its unrivaled key commands scheme, which allows users to customize a huge number of shortcuts to fit their own tactile demands, no matter how bizarre. Wavetable certainly holds its own, though — a two-oscillator plus sub wavetable synth with over well crafted wavetables onboard, two filters, comprehensive modulation options, and a supremely accessible interface and workflow, that sounds phenomenal.
For us, those two factors tip the scales. These newcomers joined an already impressive line-up of distortion, dynamics, equalisation the integrated Channel EQ is particularly good , reverb, delay, modulation and other effect types to give you absolutely everything you need to get the mixing job done.
This round in our face-off goes either way, depending on your primary plugin needs: Live for sound design, Logic for mixing. But there are also marked differences…. In contrast, with its less stratified, comparatively accessible interface, Live is about as lean and mean as DAWs get, and the speed with which the seasoned user can fly around its Session and Arrange Views, Piano Roll and Sample Editor is something to behold.
Comments
Post a Comment